"Pic-Of-The-Week" Irises by canesisters

TheEasyGarden - Gardening Forum

Easy - Fun - Fulfilling... How Gardening Should Be

You are not logged in.

#1 05/19/2012 5:20 pm

SweetMissDaisy
Garden Ornament
From: Central TX, and a HOT zone 8
Registered: 06/06/2010
Posts: 587
Website
View My Page

ONE, and only ONE! :)

Just wondering ...

If you could ONLY grow 1 crop in your garden, what would you choose -- and why?!

Offline

 

#2 05/19/2012 5:29 pm

thistlebloom
Garden Addicted
From: North Idaho zone 5 /4ish
Registered: 12/01/2010
Posts: 3357
View My Page

Re: ONE, and only ONE! :)

I didn't even have to ponder this one Daisy, I immediately thought "Potatoes!".
They're just my favorite crop. I love the reveal at the end of the season when you dig them up and see if the new variety can pull it's weight, and if your old favorite is still number 1.

We eat a lot of potatoes so they're important that way.

I suppose there are a lot of different vegetables that would be more versatile, and give your a more rounded benefit health wise, but if your talking purely about the pleasure and satisfaction from one crop, potatoes do it for me.


I have to exercise early in the morning, before my brain figures out what I'm doing.

Online

 

#3 05/19/2012 5:47 pm

so lucky
Deeply Rooted
From: SE Missouri, Zone 6
Registered: 03/05/2011
Posts: 1572

Re: ONE, and only ONE! :)

No thinking required here: Tomatoes!


1) Best for return on investment: even a hybrid seed cost about a dime, and look how many tomatoes you can get from one plant.

2) Superior taste compared to what supermarket offers, even when tomatoes are in season at the store.

3) Compare store-bought vs home-grown other vegetables: Tomatoes have the biggest taste and cost difference. I honestly can't tell a home-grown carrot from the grocery store ones. Same for broccoli, potatoes, spinach. Store-bought sweet peppers definitely better than my home-grown. But a home-grown tomato---aah!

Online

 

#4 05/19/2012 7:17 pm

Collector
Deeply Rooted
From: Eastern Wa. Zone 5/6 ?
Registered: 09/16/2010
Posts: 1020
View My Page

Re: ONE, and only ONE! :)

thistlebloom wrote:

I didn't even have to ponder this one Daisy, I immediately thought "Potatoes!".
They're just my favorite crop. I love the reveal at the end of the season when you dig them up and see if the new variety can pull it's weight, and if your old favorite is still number 1.

We eat a lot of potatoes so they're important that way.

I suppose there are a lot of different vegetables that would be more versatile, and give your a more rounded benefit health wise, but if your talking purely about the pleasure and satisfaction from one crop, potatoes do it for me.

It's not hard to tell your from Idaho Thistle haha.


The duty of a patriot is to protect his country from its government.

                                                                Thomas Paine

Online

 

#5 05/19/2012 8:25 pm

Detlor Poultry
Cooped Up
From: Zone 3b - Ontario
Registered: 01/10/2012
Posts: 583
View My Page

Re: ONE, and only ONE! :)

Winter Squash.....

Why?

Because I love winter Squasheseses, They are easy to grow and they are HUGE! Of all the garden-able plants in the world, they have the most masculature weight rose


Jesus loves you. I was a sinner, who had trespassed many a time against Him, yet because of Him, I will Live.
http://www.theeasygarden.com/web/viewblog.php?id=8835
Detlor Poultry: Breeding High Quality, Extremely Rare and Hardy fowls since None-Of-Your-Business. I feel young right now. Don't ruin that.

Offline

 

#6 05/19/2012 8:29 pm

curly_kate
Deeply Rooted
From: Zone 6A - Southeast Indiana
Registered: 07/17/2008
Posts: 1145

Re: ONE, and only ONE! :)

I have to agree on tomatoes.  Altho strawberries might be running a close second.


“I don’t understand why when we destroy something created by man we call it vandalism, but when we destroy something by nature we call it progress.”
― Ed Begley Jr.

Online

 

#7 05/19/2012 8:44 pm

lesa
Garden Master
From: ZONE 4 UPSTATE NY
Registered: 11/10/2008
Posts: 5466
View My Page

Re: ONE, and only ONE! :)

As far as crops go- I would agree with thistle.  Potatoes rule.  However, if I could grow only one plant- it would be basil.  I intend to have a pot of it growing next to my bed in the nursing home.  Love the smell, love the taste....


"Food, a French man told me once, is the first wealth.  Grow it right, and you feel insanely rich, no matter what you own." Kristin Kimball

Online

 

#8 05/19/2012 9:08 pm

momofdrew
Deeply Rooted
From: Rochester NH
Registered: 02/09/2009
Posts: 1100
View My Page

Re: ONE, and only ONE! :)

th  your making me decide???!!!!?? th he


NO! No! no! I can't... I love them all equally...well maybe not all of them but idunno I can't decide...but I agree with everyone here...big_smile


I am Pam wife of Dave: Mom of Sergeant Andrew O Tyler, and Keith, Beth, Myk, Jef, Kevin, Dawn and Robin...and an assortment of silkie chickens... We are in Eastern NH... we have Frost up until the first full moon of June and any time after Labor day so it is a challange to have a good crop...   zone 3 or 4 depends on whos map you look at

Offline

 

#9 05/19/2012 9:56 pm

digitS'
Garden Master
From: border, ID/Wa!
Registered: 12/13/2007
Posts: 7000
View My Page

Re: ONE, and only ONE! :)

We are limited by species to one not by garden space, right?????

Sweet corn!

Steve

Last edited by digitS' (05/19/2012 10:01 pm)


Last edited by digitS' (while time was slipping away)

Online

 

#10 05/19/2012 10:42 pm

marshallsmyth
Garden Addicted
From: Lake Pillsbury California, z8
Registered: 03/21/2012
Posts: 3473
Website
View My Page

Re: ONE, and only ONE! :)

Corn
It'd all be grinding Corn

If not Corn it'd be Beans. Last year, which was the year after the Great Gopher invasion, the only plants left entirely untouched had been Beans. So after all the antigopher implementations I planted basically the only thing they left alone. Beans! Ha! Nary one Gopher last year!!!

They had left the Corn alone too.


I live in the woods at a lake in Northern California. My garden is in a smallish clearing. Calypso orchids are among the wildflowers here.

Online

 

Board footer

Show recent posts

© Copyright TheEasyGarden.com

[ Generated in 0.119 seconds, 11 queries executed ]

BackYardChickens.com  |  TheEasyGarden.com   |  SufficientSelf.com  |  BackYardHerds.com  |