What we are seeing in all these compost threads and folks relating what has worked for them -- are differences in material and environment. I think RidgeRunner describes his technique well in Noahsmom's thread. Canesisters has been getting continuing ideas on her "from 'community garden' - into 'first try at a garden'" - here we have another with BJ talking about what is essentially "sheet" composting to prepare ground for gardening and now going on to 3-bin composting.
I struggled a bit with composting a long time ago. I remember investing quite a bit of work into piles of rain-damaged alfalfa hay and cow manure during one fall and then using that material in the spring. Oh, it began composting quite well. I can still remember the big square piles steaming and melting a covering of snow right thru a terrible northern Idaho winter. By spring, I had compost - right in the middle of the squares. The composting had hollowed them out like chimneys! All of my careful layering had not accomplished anything on the outer foot, or so.
After that, I think I developed patience. Soon, an 18 month schedule became
composting de rigueur in my garden. I would "build" one thru the growing season with special attention about the 1st of July & after 1st frost. By spring of the following year, redworms will be
massing in that material! The next spring, it is ready to use with very good texture, throughout. I'd have to pull weeds out of it during the first year since it never really heats up enuf to kill the weed seed on the surface. Also, that surface would be soil.
Initially, the "pile" went in a pit about 8" deep. The soil can be held out for use on the pile later in the season. Around the 1st of July, I'd really try to get it cooking with the addition of manure. More manure was applied at the end of the season and then the pile was "capped" with soil. My bins in one garden were concrete blocks but elsewhere, I would just try to get the soil piled around the sides as best as I could.
This semi-subterranean approach was to conserve moisture. Even tho' the piles were beside the gardens and benefited from the sprinklers, moisture-retention would be a problem without this soil covering and contact. Here, we can have next to zero rain during the summer months and humidity below 20% every summer afternoon.
I once had a neighbor who build an above-ground pile with wire netting and posts for legs. It was really quite remarkable how the "compost" was preserved in that bin with air on all sides. I'd go so far as to say that the material was petrified

. The bin stood for years in the same condition, long after he stopped gardening. Finally, one leg rotted off at the soil level and it collapsed. Then, and only then, the organic material he had put in there began to decay

.
Steve