Need some feedback on this post

hdan

Garden Ornament
Joined
Apr 6, 2024
Messages
181
Reaction score
380
Points
95
Location
Zone 7a
Run across this online, just wondering if there's any truth to this.
Screenshot_20250802_172259_Google.jpg
 

flowerbug

Garden Master
Joined
Oct 15, 2017
Messages
18,251
Reaction score
29,993
Points
427
Location
mid-Michigan, USoA
if you are planting a few beans you can do that sort of thing, but really how much difference is it really? do you think the bean root can't figure out which way to grow even if it is pointed up or down? and if you point the eye down that means the top part has to twist around as much as the root would have to twist the other way? so perhaps they should be planted on the side with the eye pointed east or west or south or north or south-southwest?

i plant beans a few cm (3-5 or so) deep so there is no need to worry about the bean being in the soil. also i do tamp the soil down around the bean when planting to make sure there is good seed to soil contact and i've usually had very good germination rates. keep it moist but not sodden.
 

hdan

Garden Ornament
Joined
Apr 6, 2024
Messages
181
Reaction score
380
Points
95
Location
Zone 7a
I think your right. Haven't had a problem before with germination tossing them in a hole. I planted some couple weeks ago and out of 93 seeds only 8 germinated and produced leaves. I believe the reason was the seeds wasn't stored properly. I will be replanting green beans in couple days.
 

R2elk

Deeply Rooted
Joined
Jan 24, 2021
Messages
209
Reaction score
640
Points
145
Location
Natrona County, Wyoming
I think your right. Haven't had a problem before with germination tossing them in a hole. I planted some couple weeks ago and out of 93 seeds only 8 germinated and produced leaves. I believe the reason was the seeds wasn't stored properly. I will be replanting green beans in couple days.
Poor storage, old seeds or soil too high in Nitrogen will all cause poor germination.
 

Latest posts

Top