My carrot experiment of 2025 & observations thus far.
To my surprise, for the most part I have not detected major differences in most of the carrot varieties I'm growing. I can't recall now how many I planted, but probably around 15. I bought almost every one available on the retail shelves, and ordered a few online. That said, where there actually are differences it is quite dramatic. A small few really stand out. We've had only very limited amount of frosts, so really giving any flavor rating is somewhat premature. Post cold weather is the real test, and I'll leave that for later in October.
'Kuroda' has been my favorite carrot so far. Both for the sweet taste and the remarkable size it can achieve in a short period. Of all of them, that would be the overall winner. It's not too long or too short either, easy to pick. It's a great carrot and a standout.
'Kyoto Red' had a remarkably sweet flavor by August, superlative flavor. The color is intriguing as well, they're pink. Very juicy and succulent carrot, with a fresh snappy flavor. Absolutely no bitterness like some carrots can have in hot weather. I didn't like that some of the plants bolted though. But it was in the hottest part of the carrot bed.
'Manpukuji' - now this carrot you can spot just from the foliage. I'm actually really sad that I can't save carrot seed and will be dependent on others to have seed for this one from now on. I'll never be without it. I might try the odds someday and see what happens if I do save the seeds. The thickness of the main stems of the leaf tops is really huge, you can tell by looking at them that this is an unusual carrot. Sort of like a carrot for giants. And I purposely planted these in the sandiest soil I have and it worked. These carrots can grow to 6 feet long, though they'd probably need a longer season that what I have for that. I'm waiting until mid to late October to measure them, but they're long that's for sure. At least for my garden. Taste is off the charts.
All the Nantes (Touchon, Coreless, Half Long etc.) taste more or less the same, sweet and good. And all fairly quick to grow which I like too. Blunt ends.
'Black Nebula' had quite poor germ rates, & I was surprised to see how big the few survivors got given that they were crowded and shaded by Shirley poppies which I planted over them. The taste is
barely passable, watery and insipid. It's surprisingly poor for a carrot, but the health benefits are probably significant. I do find its looks utterly ravashing.
The Manpukuji carrot was long enough that it had to be dug out with a tool. This one was overcrowded so is possibly smaller than some of the others. I'm sooo curious to dig them all up.